Introduction of intellectual accounting systems in retail electricity markets - legal implications for the population

Authors


candidate of Law, associate Professor, head of department
Russia, International Law Institute
Bestuzheva.lena@yandex.ru


Russia, International Law Institute
yana08101998@mail.ru


Russia, International Law Institute
darja.yudina1999@yandex.ru


Russia, Bauman Moscow State Technical University
surnov.sergey@gmail.com


candidate of Engineering, senior lecturer
Russia, International Law Institute
surnov53@gmail.com

Abstract

The article analyzes the regulatory impact of Federal Law No. 522 of December 27, 2018, which prescribes the creation of intelligent electric energy metering systems. It is shown that the law leads to a violation of the fundamental principle of the functioning of the electric power industry, which provides for a legislative ban on combining electric power transmission activities with its sale and purchase activities, as well as to monopolization of electric power and electricity meters in the retail markets, and the growth of corruption opportunities. It is concluded that the financial burden of creating and operating intelligent systems is unreasonably placed on the population. The privacy issue of the data collected by the intelligent system has been completely ignored. The application of the law will have the most negative consequences. Measures have been proposed to prevent these consequences.

Keywords

retail electric energy market, intelligent metering systems, intelligent electric energy meter, Smart grid.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Read also

Suggested citation

Bestuzhevа Elena Vladimirovna , Kalinskaia Yana Igorevna , Skorykh Daria Mihajlovna , Surnov Sergey Grigorjevich , Surnov Sergey Ivanovich
Introduction of intellectual accounting systems in retail electricity markets - legal implications for the population// Modern Management Technology. ISSN 2226-9339. – #2 (92). Art. # 9217. Date issued: . Available at: https://sovman.ru/en/article/9217/

Full article text is available only in Russian.
Please select from the menu Russian language and continue reading.


References

  1. Smart meter // Wikipedia. URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_meter
  2. Perry L. Internet of Things for Architects // Publisher: Packt Publishing. January 2018.524 p.
  3. Smart grid // Wikipedia. URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_grid
  4. Bychkovskiy I.A. SMART MONITORING: more than “smart metering” in housing and communal services [SMART MONITORING: bol’she, chem «umnyy uchet» v ZHKKH]/ Bychkovskiy I.A. [et al.] // Energy Saving. 2017. No.6. S.38-41.
  5. On legislative support of state policy in the field of energy conservation and energy efficiency. Decision of the Presidium of the Council of Legislators of the Russian Federation at the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation [O zakonodatel’nom obespechenii gosudarstvennoy politiki v oblasti energosberezheniya i povysheniya energeticheskoy effektivnosti. Resheniye Prezidiuma Soveta zakonodateley RF pri Federal’nom Sobranii RF]. 04.24.2017 year. St. Petersburg // URL: http://szrf.km.duma.gov.ru/upload/site53/7._Ob_obespechenii_gos.politiki_v_oblasti_energosberezheniya_(1).pdf
  6. Transcript of parliamentary hearings on the topic “Problems of the development of intelligent accounting systems and ways to solve them.” [Stenogramma parlamentskikh slushaniy na temu “Problemy razvitiya intellektual’nykh sistem ucheta i puti ikh resheniya”]. March 23, 2018 // URL: http://council.gov.ru/media/files/tQ7g2ALr98am9A5IJ3E2bXLYvxbJSZ7a.pdf
  7. Draft Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of 12/19/2018 N02 / 07 / 12-18 / 00087050 “On approval of the rules for providing access to the minimum set of functions of intelligent systems for metering electric energy (power)” [Proyekt postanovleniya Pravitel’stva RF ot 19.12.2018 N02/07/12-18/00087050 “Ob utverzhdenii pravil predostavleniya dostupa k minimal’nomu naboru funktsiy intellektual’nykh sistem ucheta elektricheskoy energii (moshchnosti)”]. Ed. from 05/31/2019 //
  8. URL: http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?from=47922-0&rnd=15C27AB2B91B056A50987E0B9E70818E&req=doc&base=PNPA&div=PRJ&n=43874&diff=47922#23fwxn
  9. Smart electricity meters: seven advantages and not a single drawback [Umnyye schetchiki elektroenergii: sem’ dostoinstv i ni odnogo nedostatka]. 07.24.2019 // URL: https://gorod48.ru/news/1863510/
  10. Draft Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation “On Amending the Basic Provisions for the Functioning of Retail Electricity Markets and Other Regulatory Legal Acts of the Russian Federation on Improving the Organization of Electricity Metering” [Proyekt Postanovleniya Pravitel’stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii “O vnesenii izmeneniy v Osnovnyye polozheniya funktsionirovaniya roznichnykh rynkov elektricheskoy energii i inyye normativnyye pravovyye akty Rossiyskoy Federatsii po voprosam sovershenstvovaniya organizatsii ucheta elektricheskoy energii”] (prepared by the Ministry of Energy of the Russian Federation on February 18, 2019) // URL: https: // www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/56684087/#review
  11. Bestuzheva Ye.V. Detailed data on energy consumption in housing and communal services: privacy issues [Detalizirovannyye dannyye o potreblenii energoresursov v ZHKKH: voprosy konfidentsial’nosti]/ Bestuzheva Ye.V. [et al.] // Business Security. 2019. №5. S. 53-57.
  12. Bychkovskiy I.A. SMART MONITORING technology: results of field tests [Tekhnologiya SMART MONITORING: rezul’taty naturnykh ispytaniy]/ Bychkovskiy I.A. [et al.] // Energy Saving. 2018. No2. S. 32-33.
  13. Surnov S. Smart Monitoring: remote-monitoring technology of power, gas, and water consumtion in Smart Cities / S. Surnov [et al.] // URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.08759
  14. Loginov V.N. Smart Monitoring – technology for remote monitoring of electricity, water, thermal energy and gas consumption in Smart City [Smart Monitoring – tekhnologiya distantsionnogo monitoringa potrebleniya elektroenergii, vody, teplovoy energii i gaza v Smart City]/ V.N. Loginov [et al.] // Transactions of MIPT. 2020. Volume 12 No. 1. S. 90-99.
  15. Conclusion No. 21734-VZH / D26i of 04/04/2019 on the assessment of the regulatory impact on the draft decree of the Government of the Russian Federation “On approval of the rules for providing access to the minimum set of functions of intelligent systems for accounting for electric energy (power)” [Zaklyucheniye № 21734-VZH/D26i ot 04.07.2019 ob otsenke reguliruyushchego vozdeystviya na proyekt postanovleniya Pravitel’stva Rossiyskoy Federatsii «Ob utverzhdenii pravil predostavleniya dostupa k minimal’nomu naboru funktsiy intellektual’nykh sistem ucheta elektricheskoy energii (moshchnosti)»] // URL: http://orv.gov.ru/Content/Item?n=30491