Development of methodological foundations and tools of economic evaluation of technology


doctor of economic Sciences, Advisor of the General Director
Russia, JSC «Central Research Institute «Electronics», Moscow
[email protected]

candidate of economic Sciences, leading researcher
Russia, JSC "Research center "INTERELECTRON", Moscow
[email protected]


The article discusses various theoretical approaches to the evaluation of technologies. The characteristic of the main stages of development of the methodology and tools of this assessment. The results of the analysis of known methods and techniques of technology assessment. A new integrated approach to the development of methodologies and tools of economic evaluation techniques used in military and civilian sectors. A toolkit implementing this approach in the form of methods and econometric models. They allow you to calculate the integral economic effect of dual use technologies when they are used in civilian and military spheres. The algorithms, criteria and indicators for economic assessment meet modern conditions of state-building and are qualitatively new methodological and instrumental basis for the regulation of technological development of the Russian economy.


Economic evaluation of technology, evaluation of dual-use technologies, efficiency, the concept of alternative cost and methodology of UNIDO, the concept of overall efficiency

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Read also

Project finance

The article was prepared with the grant support of the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (project No. 16-06-00028)

Suggested citation

Bat'kovskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich , Bat'kovskij Mikhail Aleksandrovich
Development of methodological foundations and tools of economic evaluation of technology// Modern Management Technology. ISSN 2226-9339. – #4 (76). Art. # 7609. Date issued: . Available at:

Full article text is available only in Russian.
Please select from the menu Russian language and continue reading.


  1. Avdonin B.N., Bat’kovskiy A.M., Bat’kovskiy M.A. et al. The theoretical basis and the tools for evaluating the effectiveness of the development of new technologies [Teoreticheskiye osnovy i instrumentariy otsenki effektivnosti razrabotki novykh tekhnologiy] // Electronic industry. 2014, 1. – P. 123-140.
  2. Balychev S.YU., Bat’kovskiy A.M., Bozhko V.P. Analysis of the management of the production of weapons and military equipment in foreign countries [Analiz upravleniya proizvodstvom vooruzheniya i voyennoy tekhniki v zarubezhnykh stranakh] // Electronic industry. No. 3. – P. 80-93.
  3. Bat’kovskiy A.M. Models for the formation and evaluation of the program for the innovative development of the economic system [Modeli formirovaniya i otsenki programmy innovatsionnogo razvitiya ekonomicheskoy sistemy] // Financial Analytics: Problems and Solutions. 2011. No. 9. – P. 14-23.
  4. Bat’kovskiy A.M. Forecasting and modeling of innovation development of economic systems [Prognozirovaniye i modelirovaniye innovatsionnogo razvitiya ekonomicheskikh sistem]. – Moscow: ontoPrint, 2011. – 202 pp.
  5. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Bat’kovskiy M.A., Beloshevich M.M. et al. The methodology and tools of management of innovative activity of economic systems in terms of transnationalization of the economy and its fragile post-crisis development [Metodologiya i instrumentariy upravleniya innovatsionnoy deyatel’nost’yu ekonomicheskikh sistem v usloviyakh transnatsionalizatsii ekonomiki i yeye neustoychivogo postkrizisnogo razvitiya] / A.M. Bat’kovskiy. – Moscow: MESI, 2010. – 360 pp.
  6. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Bat’kovskiy M.A., Bozhko V.P. et al. Strategy of Russian companies in the development of the modern period: Theory and Methodology [Strategiya razvitiya rossiyskikh predpriyatiy v sovremennyy period: teoriya i metodologiya] – Moscow: MESI, 2009. – 451 pp.
  7. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Bat’kovskiy M.A., Royko G.A. et al. Methods for optimizing the life cycle of the development of radioelectronic products [Metody optimizatsii zhiznennogo tsikla razrabotki radioelektronnoy produktsii] // Scientific bulletins of the Belgorod State University. Series History. Political science. Economy. Computer science. Vol. 31. No. 15-1 (186). – P. 121-127.
  8. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Bat’kovskiy M.A., Fomina A.V. et al. Optimization of program activities in the development of the military-industrial complex [Optimizatsiya programmnykh meropriyatiy razvitiya oboronno-promyshlennogo kompleksa] / A.M. Bat’kovskiy, A.V. Fomina – Moscow: Thesaurus, 2014. – 504 с.
  9. Bat’kovskiy M.A., Klochkov V.V., Fomina A.V. et al. Strategies for implementation of innovative technologies in the enterprises of the military-industrial complex [Strategii vnedreniya innovatsionnykh tekhnologiy na predpriyatiyakh oboronno-promyshlennogo kompleks] // Questions of radio electronics. 2015. No. 6 (6). – P. 232-251.
  10. Bat’kovskiy M.A., Kravchuk P.V., Fomina A.V. Development of methods and tools of economic evaluation of technologies and research and development activities [Razvitiye metodov i instrumentariya ekonomicheskoy otsenki tekhnologiy i nauchno-issledovatel’skikh i opytno-konstruktorskikh rabot] // Questions of radio electronics. 2015. No. 1 (1). – P. 186-201.
  11. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Kravchuk P.V. Development of methodology for technology assessment [Razvitiye metodologii otsenki tekhnologiy] // National management: problems and development prospects: a collection of scientific papers on the basis of the materials of the I International Scientific and Practical Conference on March 25, 2016. – Nizhny Novgorod: Professional Science – 2016. – 157-178.
  12. Bat’kovskiy M.A., Kravchuk P.V., Fomina A.V. Economic assessment of dual-use technologies [Ekonomicheskaya otsenka tekhnologiy dvoynogo naznacheniya] // Questions of radio electronics. 2015, No. 4 (4). – P. 222-231.
  13. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Fomina A.V., Bat’kovskiy M.A. et al. Improving the defense-industrial complex management [Sovershenstvovaniye upravleniya oboronno-promyshlennym kompleksom] / Ed. M. Bat’kovskiy, A.V. Fomina – Moscow: Thesaurus, 2016. – 474 с.
  14. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Semenova E.G., Fomina A.V. Prediction and evaluation of innovative development of economic systems [Prognozirovaniye i otsenka innovatsionnogo razvitiya ekonomicheskikh sistem] // Questions of radio electronics. No. 2. – P. 280-303.
  15. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Fomina A.V. State regulation and support of the military-industrial complex [Gosudarstvennoye regulirovaniye i podderzhka oboronno-promyshlennogo kompleksa] // Radio industries. 2015, 3. – P. 280-301.
  16. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Fomina A.V. The need and objectives of the modernization of the military-industrial complex of Russia [Neobkhodimost’ i zadachi modernizatsii oboronno-promyshlennogo kompleksa Rossii] // Electronic industry. No. 4. – P. 3-15
  17. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Fomina A.V., Khrustalev Ye.YU. The risks of implementing military projects [Riski realizatsii proyektov sozdaniya produktsii voyennogo naznacheniya] // Questions of radio electronics, 2014, No. 2. – P. 32-52.
  18. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Fomina A.V. Development of tools for economic evaluation of dual-use technologies [Razvitiye instrumentariya ekonomicheskoy otsenki tekhnologiy dvoynogo primeneniya] // Professional of the year 2017: collection of articles 3 of the international scientific and practical contest. – Science and Education. – P. 27-33.
  19. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Fomina A.V., Bat’kovskiy M.A. et al. Management of development of military-industrial complex [Upravleniye razvitiyem oboronno-promyshlennogo kompleksa] / A.M. Bat’kovskiy, A.V. Fomina – Moscow: Thesaurus, 2015. – 536 с.
  20. Bat’kovskiy A.M., Fomina A.V., Bat’kovskiy M.A. et al. Risk management of innovative development base of high-tech industries [Upravleniye riskami innovatsionnogo razvitiya bazovykh vysokotekhnologichnykh otrasley] / A.M. Bat’kovskiy, A.V. Fomina – Moscow: Thesaurus, 2015. – 332 pp.
  21. Konson A.S. Economy scientific research [Ekonomika nauchnykh razrabotok] – Moscow: Economy, 1968. – 208 pp.
  22. Methodical recommendations according to efficiency of investment projects, and their selection for financing (2nd edition). Approved. Ministry of Economy of the Russian Federation, the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation, the Russian State Committee for Construction, Architecture and Housing Policy BK 477 from 21.06.1999 [Metodicheskiye rekomendatsii po otsenke effektivnosti investitsion-nykh proyektov i ikh otboru dlya finansirovaniya (2-ya redaktsiya). Utv. Minekonomiki RF, Minfinom RF, Gosudarstvennym komitetom RF po stroitel’noy, arkhitekturnoy i zhilishchnoy politike No. BK 477 ot 21.06.1999 g.]. URL
  23. Methodical recommendations according to efficiency of investment projects and their selection for funding. Approved by the State Construction Committee of Russia, the Ministry of Economy of the Russian Federation, the Ministry of Finance March 31, 1994 7-12/47. [Metodicheskiye rekomendatsii po otsenke effektivnosti investitsionnykh proyektov i ikh otboru dlya finansirovaniya. Utverzhdeny Gosstroyem Rossii, Minekonomiki RF, Minfinom RF 31 marta 1994 g. No. 7-12/47]. URL
  24. Decree number 60 SCCT USSR, the Presidium of the USSR 52 from 03.03.1988 “On approval of the” Guidelines on the integrated assessment of the effectiveness of measures aimed at accelerating scientific and technological progress [Postanovleniye GKNT SSSR № 60, Prezidiuma AN SSSR No. 52 ot 03.03.1988 «Ob utverzhdenii «Metodicheskikh rekomendatsiy po kompleksnoy otsenke effektivnosti meropriyatiy, napravlennykh na uskoreniye nauchno-tekhnicheskogo progressa»]” URL
  25. Fomina A.V., Avdonin B.N., Bat’kovskiy A.M. et al. Managing the development of high-tech enterprises high-tech industries [Upravleniye razvitiyem vysokotekhnologichnykh predpriyatiy naukoyemkikh otrasley promyshlennosti] / A.V. Fomina – Moscow: Creative economy, 2014. – 400 pp.
  26. Batkovskiy A.M., Batkovskiy M.A., Fomina A.V. et al. Implementation Risks in Investment Projects on Boosting High-Tech Business Production Capacity: Analysis and Management // Journal of Applied Economic Sciences. Romania: European Research Centre of Managerial Studies in Business Administration, 2016, XI, Issue 6(44), Fall 2016, Р 1200-1209.
  27. Bozhko V.P., Batkovsky A.M., Batkovsky M.A. et al. Modeling technological relations in the structure of production (Моделирование технологических связей в структуре производства). // Статистика и Экономика. 2014, № 1. – С. 36-39.
  28. Batkovskiy A.M., Batkovskiy M.A., Fomina A.V. et al. Development of Economic Assessment of Technologies // Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences. MCSER Publishing, Rome-Italy, 2015, Vol 6, No 4, S4, August, 22-33 Doi:10.5901/mjss.2015.v6n4s4p22.